Date: Mon, 4 Mar 2002 11:24:48 -0800 From: "IronMan Mike Curtis" Subject: Re: Notice: Yahoo groups down.... along with all the other harmonica email groups.
>
We still have the newsgroups, which are 1. noncentral, and 2. run under nntp protocol instead of the centralized listserver protocol.
This is quite the paradox. One of the goals of the original DARPAnet/ ARPAnet project was to be the elimination of central points of failure. With Yahoo et al gobbling up everything in site (excuse the pun), and MicroSoft foisting on us that abomination they have the nerve to call an OS, WinDoze, we're right back to the "central point of failure" that the military was seeking to eliminate with the tcp/ip suite of protocols.
The Internet is USUALLY reliable. But when we put ALL our eggs into one basket, when that one basket fails, it's disastrous.
I'm not talking about the harp lists. That's trivial, even for us hard core raving harp maniacs. Businesses depend on the internet. Some phone systems are using internet for long distance and such. And there are a lot of things going on that most of us would never even think of.
On ham radio, we have computers. In fact, we have a worldwide network of bulletin board systems, via which we send general bulletins, news items of interest to hams, emergency traffic, and such. Most of the stuff is trivial, but it's part of "staying in practice". When "the big one" hits, this network is there in splendid redundancy to pass along health and welfare messages, emergency communications for various agencies, and such (so when you see one of those "huge ugly antennas" in your neighborhood, don't complain - instead, make friends with the one person who might be able to get your messages out when all else fails).
One of the shames about this network is that there are people who sabotage it by using the neternet to forward messages. While it's cheaper (radios and antennas cost big bucks!) and faster (much of the network uses 1200 baud, 300 baud, and even slower radio paths), it's also going through a "central point of failure".
This outage of Yahoogroups is a very good argument for having multiple listservers and not just one central server that can glitch, be sabotaged, shut their doors on a whim, etc. The Internet should be diverse, and anything but homogenous.
We should also have a diversity of hardware and operating systems. Virtually all viruses are directed against MicroSoft. While I have no direct proof, only a suspicion, I suspect at least some is from programmers and developers that MicroSoft has monopolistically put out of business via barely legal (or outright illegal) tactics.
This is one big reason many of us are so excited at the emergence of the Linux OS - and MicroSoft is so afraid of it. Being open architecture, all the source code is freely available for programmers to work on, debug, etc. (MS stuff is closed architecture - if you need to mod it or fix bugs, tough). The good improvements get adopted into "approved" releases. The bad ones don't. And with different releases, it's nigh impossible to "hack" the whole internet the way MS specific virii do.
- -IronMan Mike Curtis http://www.IronmanCurtis.com Jam w/ IronMan & Band Tue 8pm-mid - Starboard Attitude 202 The Pier, Redondo CA See Mik~Santa Monica 3rd St Promenade - email for times Songs, reviews, pix, Web Vide~http://www.mp3.com/IronmanCurtis